Whether you want a mascara that's safe to use with eyelash extensions or you have super-sensitive eyes, there are quite a few oil-free mascaras that deserve a spot in your makeup bag. The best oil-free mascaras are water-based, mild, and washable—but not waterproof. Not only is waterproof mascara difficult to remove without using an oil-based cleanser (and oil is the enemy of eyelash extensions), but any rubbing or tugging around the eyes can be irritating to sensitive eyes and can also mess up false lashes.
If you have eyelash extensions, there are mascaras specifically designed for this purpose, so when in doubt, buying one of these is the easiest way to ensure you're getting an oil-free mascara. But there are other water-based and oil-free mascaras out there, even if they're not specifically designed for eyelash extensions. In fact, some of the most popular drugstore mascaras are (surprisingly) oil-free.
Keep scrolling to discover five of the best oil-free mascaras that are all water-based, gentle, and safe for sensitive eyes, eyelash extensions, contact lens wearers, and more. Then, choose one of the best oil-free makeup removers.
1. Best Oil-Free Mascara Overall
Xtreme Lashes Length & Volume Mascara is designed for semi-permanent eyelash extensions, but the water-based formula enriched with panthenol is also great for contact lens wearers and those with sensitive eyes. The brand recommends that you apply mascara from the middle of your lashes to the tips (in other words, above the adhesive), which is great advice for any mascara you use with lash extensions. Like all the other oil-free mascaras on this list, you can easily remove it with a mild oil-free makeup remover or cleanser.
2. Classic oil-free mascara
Since 1971, the iconic pink tube has graced countless makeup artists' kits and graced the lashes of legions of fans. Who knew this classic formula can give lashes definition and length without the use of oil, without feeling sticky or clumpy? It's both pretty and layerable—one coat will give you deep black tones and some length, while two or three will give you a boost of drama. Stick with the washable (not waterproof) version, or if you just want a little definition and curl, you can opt for a clear mascara (pro tip, it also makes a great brow gel).
3. Another fan-favorite oil-free mascara
Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara is currently the best-selling mascara on Amazon with over 200,000 five-star ratings and is loved for its powerful appeal and dramatic effect, whether you use it with or without your lashes. Brings powerful glamor and dramatic extensions to lashes of all lengths and thicknesses or not. This mascara uses a straight fiber brush to define and color each lash, making it easy to reach even those tricky inner corners. It's oil- and fragrance-free and comes from a PETA-certified cruelty-free brand.
4. The best double-sided oil-free mascara
The GladGirl Lashe EnMasse Mascara is the second mascara on this list and is designed specifically for those with eyelash extensions. The vegan and oil-free formula gets its lightweight moisture from glycerin, wheat protein and cotton. This clever double-sided wand gives users more control over how to apply, define and shape lashes, with fluffy ends for added volume and curved ends for a more natural finish.
5. Writer’s Picks
If you have sensitive eyes, try PÜR's Full Charged Mascara, which I found to be super gentle and non-irritating, and overall pleasant to wear. I'm someone with sensitive eyes and also rub my eyes (too) often, but this didn't cause any itching nor did it make my lashes feel sticky or heavy. The conditioning formula contains biotin and peptides to promote healthy lashes, as well as panthenol to soften lashes, and is vegan and cruelty-free; so it's also a good choice for those with dry, brittle lashes (although it Does not rely on any oil for nourishment).
You might also like
This foaming eyelash shampoo is gentle enough to remove false eyelashes/eyelashes without damaging them, and can also be used before applying false eyelashes to prep and clean them if you're doing it at home. It comes in a convenient pump bottle with a soft brush so you can carefully apply the cleanser to your lashes, and is fragrance-free and safe for sensitive skin.
