Your phone provides entertainment, helps you connect with others, and organizes your life, so it's natural to want to protect it with one of the most durable phone cases available. The battle between CASETiFY and Otterbox for the title of best phone case may have surfaced during your search, and I've delved into the nitty-gritty of both to determine the pros and cons of each. Here’s how the two brands compare:
Drop protection
- Winner: CASETiFY
Both brands design cases that will protect your device from drops, drops, and more thanks to military-grade drop protection that requires the case to be dropped from four feet 26 times to prove the case's durability. Edges, corners, front and back can withstand multiple impacts. Additionally, cases from both brands feature raised edges around the camera to protect the lens, additional corner protection, and raised bezel edges on the front to protect the screen in the event of a drop.
Four popular models are listed below, all of which meet or exceed five times military standards. However, CASETiFY wins with the CASETiFY Bounce Case, which features extra corner protection and six times the processing power of military standards—the highest of any model.
- CASETiFY stretch protective case for iPhone 14: 6 times more likely to be dropped than military standard
- CASETiFY Ultra Impact Case for iPhone 14: 5x more drops than military standard
- OtterBox FRĒ series for iPhone 14: 5 times more resistant to drops than military standards, waterproof and can survive 2 meters of water for 1 hour
- OtterBox DEFENDER XT for iPhone 14: 5x more drops than military standard
Waterproof and scratch resistant
- Winner: Otter Box
The OtterBox FRĒ range is able to be safely immersed in water up to two meters deep for up to an hour; something the CASETiFY cases lack.
Additionally, both the OtterBox FRĒ Series and DEFENDER XT feature built-in screen protectors to prevent screen scratches. If scratches are a concern, we also recommend pairing the CASETiFY case (as well as the OtterBox Symmetry+ case) with a screen protector.
style
- Winner: Tie (CASETiFY print, Otterbox solid)
If you want a more colorful print on your phone case, CASETiFY may be the better choice, but if you're looking for neutral colors or simple designs, both brands will have something to suit your aesthetic. Otterbox typically uses neutral colors and designs for its cases, while CASETiFY is known for branching out into more artistic designs and colorful expressions. While Otterbox has some floral and color options, CASETiFY has more artist collaborations and humorous prints, with Otterbox mostly making solid colors.
MagSafe compatibility
- Winner: Tie
If your phone is an iPhone 12, 13, or 14, you may be looking for MagSafe compatibility. Both brands' most popular models are MagSafe compatible.
price
- Winner: Otter Box
Prices for both brands vary based on the model's level of protection, with the most protective cases costing more. The most protective models of both brands (CASETiFY Bounce Case and OtterBox FRĒ series) are both above $80, with the OtterBox FRĒ series, which varies in price (depending on the color chosen), being more or less expensive. CASETiFY Bounce Case.
As for the mid-level protection models of both brands (CASETiFY Ultra Impact Case and OtterBox DEFENDER XT), the OtterBox DEFENDER ) and continue. OtterBox Symmetry+ case), and the price of the OtterBox Symmetry+ case is a full $18 lower. If you want screen protection, OtterBox can also save you money because screen protection is built-in on the FRĒ Series and DEFENDER XT models, eliminating the need to purchase a screen protector as an add-on.
Another thing worth noting is that CASETiFY offers the Ultra Impact and Impact Cases, which drop MagSafe compatibility for $10 less, which is a significant cost savings if that feature isn't important to you.
- CASETiFY Bounce Case for iPhone 14: $82 at Amazon
- CASETiFY Ultra Impact Case for iPhone 14: $78 at Amazon
- CASETify Impact Protective Case for iPhone 14: $68 at Amazon
- OtterBox FRĒ Series for iPhone 14: $72-$87 on Amazon
- OtterBox DEFENDER XT for iPhone 14: $65-$70 on Amazon
- OtterBox Symmetry+ Case for iPhone 14: $50 at Amazon
sustainable development
- Winner: CASETiFY
The materials and methods used to construct cases vary widely. In terms of production methods, CASETiFY excels in sustainability – the brand incorporates plant-based and recycled materials into its designs, and takes sustainability seriously with ISO14001 certified production facilities and carbon neutrality goals. In 2021, CASETiFY is even launching a line of super-compostable bins made with ecotify, a proprietary blend of biopolymers, starch and bamboo. Otterbox does make efforts to be more sustainable, such as using packaging made from sustainable materials and using recycled plastic to build some of its boxes.
in conclusion
If you're looking for colorful, artistic, or unique designs, CASETiFY is the way to go, but both brands offer a variety of solid and neutral colors.
If your phone is prone to falling, the CASETiFY pop-up case model is your best choice. However, if water is a major concern, the OtterBox FRĒ range is the only waterproof model.
Best anti-fall phone case: CASETiFY Bounce Case
advantage
- Drop protection up to 6 times better than military standards
- Available in a variety of prints and clear solid colors
- Made from recycled and plant-based materials
- Shock-absorbing material at corners
shortcoming
- price
- Add a little bulk to your phone
This highly protective case is available in a variety of clear solid colors, as well as a variety of colorful prints. It has the strongest drop protection of any OtterBox or CASETiFY model—six times more drop protection than military-grade standards. CASETiFY explains that the case can absorb 95% of impact forces. Like most of their cases, this case is made from 65% recycled and plant-based materials such as bamboo to create a super strong and biodegradable material that is 100% recyclable and also made in Manufactured in a production facility equipped with rainwater harvesting, recycling systems and other sustainable practices.
Best Waterproof Phone Case: OtterBox FRĒ Series
advantage
- Drop protection 5 times better than military standards
- Waterproof, can be submerged under 2 meters of water for 1 hour
- Made from 60% recycled plastic
- Built-in screen protector
shortcoming
- Limited color selection, no prints available
The OtterBox FRĒ range offers impressive protection against everyday drops and accidents. It has five times more drop protection than military standards, a built-in screen protector to prevent screen scratches, and it's submersible, meaning you won't panic if you spill your iced coffee on it. While it's available in a variety of solid colors, there aren't any patterns or prints.
Other situations to consider:
CASETiFY Super Impact Box
The Casetify Ultra Impact Case has more printing options and slightly slimmer corners than the Bounce Case, but still offers impressive drop protection with five times the drop protection of military-grade standards. If MagSafe compatibility isn't important to you, there's also a non-MagSafe version available for $10 less.
OtterBox DEFENDER XT Series
DEFENDER XT offers five times the standard of military-grade drop resistance and comes with a built-in screen protector for impressive protection — better drop protection than the CASETiFY Impact case at nearly the same price Protect. Like the high-end FRĒ series, it also has a built-in screen protector. Unfortunately, it doesn't offer prints—just solid colors and some partially transparent options.
CASETiFY impact cases
CASETiFY impact-resistant cases still offer impressive drop protection, four times that of military-grade standards, and are available in 20 different patterns. Don’t like purple accents? Instead, there's a list with black accents. There's also a non-MagSafe-compatible version that's $10 cheaper.
OtterBox Symmetry+ Series
Known for its rugged design, the OtterBox case measures just over half an inch wide and has a one-piece construction made from synthetic rubber and 50% recycled polycarbonate. It has three times the drop rating of military standards, and while some more rugged designs have port covers to keep out lint and dust, like the CASETiFY, this model is plug-and-play capable. It also features antimicrobial protection, a built-in lanyard attachment, and is available in seven colors and prints.
